Skip to main content
Teacher smiling with students

Teacher Appreciation vs. Appreciation of the Teacher

May 5, 2025

Teacher Appreciation vs. Appreciation of the Teacher

Amber Chandler offers a heartfelt and humorous reminder that what students value most isn't just instruction—it’s authenticity, kindness, and the humanity their teachers bring to the classroom. This Teacher Appreciation Week, discover what really leaves a lasting impact.

Share

Share On Facebook
Share On Twitter
Share On Pinterest
Share On LinkedIn
Email

Teacher Appreciation Week is here, and if you are like me, you are looking for some free goodies around town, but fully recognize that appreciation isn’t something teachers have come to expect. I’m not whining, trust me, but teachers know that May is a month of chaos, and survival is often the name of the game. If someone has something nice to say about us, then all the better. As I was thinking about what to write for this blog, I posed this question to my son and his girlfriend as I was driving her home: “What do you appreciate about your teachers?” I’m going to share our conversation because it was so surprising and, frankly, a bit more inspiring than the freebies I’m still looking for

Oliver: 

I like it when teachers treat you like a human. Like you aren’t just a student in their class, but an actual person.

Carlyin (girlfriend): 

I love it when teachers are happy to be there, not just because they are getting paid. Like Mr. S, Mr. G, you (I taught Carlyin in eighth grade). 

Oliver:

I appreciate when teachers are funny.

Me:

Like dad joke funny or ironic funny or accidentally funny?

Oliver:

All of them, honestly. When teachers are goofy and aren’t afraid to be human. 

Carlyin:

The teachers who dress up for spirit days or joke around with you are good too.

Me:

I was a minion when I had you, Carlyin. It is outside of my comfort zone, actually. I’m glad that it paid off. But, what if you aren’t funny? I’m not really funny.

Oliver:

That’s OK too. Maybe it isn’t exactly ‘funny’ that I mean. I guess I also mean that they are themselves, whatever that is for them. Authentic. I like Mr. K, and he isn’t funny.

Me: 

What else do y’all appreciate?

Oliver:

I still remember in second grade when a kid in my class had a dog that died, and Mrs. R stopped everything, and we sat in a circle for like half the morning, telling stories about our pets and why we will always remember them. Some of us were crying, and we still kept going. It was one of the best things I remember about elementary school, even though it was wicked sad. 

Carlyin:

I cried a lot in school.

Me:

Me too. My school nurse was like my best friend. What about what they teach? Or how? 

Carlyin:

Sort of, but less than you think.

Oliver:

I don’t have to like whatever it is much, but I like when they do. It rubs off on you, I guess.

Around this time, we pulled into her driveway, and the conversation was over, just like that. However, as I sat down to write this, it occurred to me how much “wisdom” was dropped on me tonight. Neither of them really said much about what was taught, or even how, but rather they cared about us, the teachers, and who we are. 

Teacher Appreciation Day, or Week, or Month is a good time to remember that it isn’t what we do that kiddos appreciate, but who we are.

When I think about the teachers (and school nurses) who were my favorites, I don’t appreciate them for what they did, but who they were. Dr. Bennert was an aging hippy who showed us actual slides from her travels to Europe, reminiscing in a way that I am just now understanding, but I loved then. Dr. Myers challenged us to think about not only journalism, but also its moral implications, often sharing times he’d felt unethical or “icky” about the job. Mr. Burger stayed up late with us on our Key Club field trip playing cards in the lobby, betting Jolly Ranchers. 

Looking around my school, I see exactly what Oliver and his girlfriend were talking about. My co-teacher and best friend is cringy on purpose, sings whenever she wants, and talks sports as students come in. Nicole, a young teacher I mentored, staged an actual “Ceremony of Twelves” from The Giver and invited our assistant principal to be the chief elder. A friend of mine, and teacher across the hall, has a giant cut out of Edgar Allan Poe who she dresses up for holidays. 

This Teacher Appreciation Week (I could have sworn it was a month), I ask you to think about this: What do students appreciate about you? Are you artsy? Do you remember their pets' names? Do you bring snacks? Is there a lesson that you’ve imbued with your life experiences, sharing more than curriculum? Are you a coach? Do you stay after school to watch your students’ games? 

Here’s the thing: I know you do. Teachers are just people, bringing all kinds of talents and interests and personality traits to their classrooms. You may not be every kiddo’s favorite, but you are someone’s, and that matters. Teacher Appreciation Day, or Week, or Month is a good time to remember that it isn’t what we do that kiddos appreciate, but who we are

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Want to see more stories like this one? Subscribe to the SML e-newsletter!

Amber Chandler
  Amber Chandler is a National Board Certified middle school ELA teacher in Hamburg, New York with a Master’s Degree in Literature, as well as a School Building Leader certification. She is the 2018 Association for Middle Level Educators’ “Educator of the Year.”  Amber has enjoyed a wide variety of... See More
Advertisement

Post a comment

Log in or sign up to post a comment.